The Negative Trait Thesaurus: A Writer’s Guide to Character Flaws by Angela Ackerman and Becca Puglisi is a comprehensive brainstorming resource that helps writers master the balancing act of crafting deeply human, memorable characters by exploring their dark sides. By providing a vast, fully indexed collection of negative traits, this guide equips writers to move beyond flat archetypes, offering actionable strategies to build layered, nuanced heroes and antagonists whose perfectly balanced strengths and weaknesses resonate with readers.
Here are the twelve most impactful takeaways from my notes on The Negative Trait Thesaurus to help you craft compelling, multi-dimensional characters:
1. Root Flaws in Past Wounds
A character’s major flaw should always trace back to a defining hurtful experience, though other minor flaws may develop organically from their environment or upbringing. These negative traits often begin as coping mechanisms to protect the character from being hurt again.
2. Use Personas to Hide Weaknesses
Characters naturally want to conceal their weaknesses from others. In social situations, they may wear a mask or “persona,” putting on a specific act to hide how they truly feel.
3. Ensure Flaws Block the Character’s Goal
A major, or “fatal,” flaw causes the hero to be stuck in some capacity at the start of the story. This specific weakness compromises their path to achieving their dreams and prevents them from reaching their full potential.
4. Align the Inner and Outer Journeys
Compelling stories feature an inner journey that closely mirrors the ups and downs of the external plot. As the protagonist strives to defeat an antagonist or external challenge, they must simultaneously overcome themselves and their greatest fears.
5. Uncover the “Lie” Fueling the Flaw
Flaws are sustained by lies and negative beliefs that stymie the character. To emerge healed and whole at the end of the arc, the character must acknowledge their past wound and see their false belief for what it is.
6. Find the Positive Side of Negative Traits
Flaws possess positive elements that can be utilized to create a well-rounded and believable character. For instance, a gullible character is easily duped, but they are also inherently trusting, friendly, and generous.
7. Pair Conflicting Traits to Build Tension
You can build tension and complicate matters for the hero by pairing characters with opposing traits. If your character has controlling tendencies, partnering them with a rebellious character who resists authority will cause serious problems.
8. Define the Moral Divide Between Hero and Villain
Antagonists suffer emotional traumas and wounding events just like heroes do. However, morality is the biggest difference between them; they might share the exact same goals, but their moral barometers will dictate how they go about achieving them.
9. Give Your Antagonist Positive Attributes
Every antagonist, regardless of how unlikable they are, needs a positive attribute or two. Adding qualities that are at odds with their dark side creates a unique and interesting villain rather than a spoiled brat with no substance.
10. Show Flaws Through Sensitivities
Telling a reader about a character’s strengths and weaknesses is a sign of lazy writing. Instead, reveal these flaws by showing how the character reacts. Show whether they panic, resort to violence, or deflect attention when their sensitive spots are threatened.
11. Create a “Zigzag” Character Arc
Flaws are not cured or diminished all at once. A realistic character arc is a zigzag where the hero takes three steps forward and two steps backward, occasionally losing control to the flaw before trying again.
12. Balance Flaws with Redeemable Qualities Early
To create flawed yet likable characters, it is important to have the right balance of negative and positive traits. Identify a strong attribute that most people value, like courage, loyalty, or generosity, then reveal it as early in the story as possible.
Disclosure: Links to Amazon.com are affiliate links. If you make a purchase after clicking one of the links, Amazon tosses a few pennies my way for the referral.
Leave a Reply